Search

SCADA Articles on SCADA World

An alternative to DCS or PLC/SCADA

2011-10-04 13:46:22views: 922ControlEngeneering

An alternative to DCS or PLC/SCADA

Traditionally, users have had a choice between a DCS or a PLC/SCADA approach when selecting a control system for use in process control applications. A key benefit of traditional DCSs was that the suppliers took a ‘systems approach’ and it was designed for large scale applications. Much of the work of integrating different parts of the system was taken care of by the DCS vendor by using a single database for the complete system. The DCS approach is to configure the system using standard control objects and faceplates, reducing engineering and providing standardisation. Most DCSs also offer fieldbus communications, tools for process optimisation and asset management packages to improve maintenance. More recently DCS suppliers have introduced more scalable solutions for smaller applications. However, there are a number of potential shortcomings in the DCS approach. Many process plants have a large number of OEM packages that need to be integrated with the overall process control system and it is unlikely that the OEM will use a DCS for their control system. In some manufacturing processes there is a requirement for different types of control; process, discrete, high speed, drive control, motion control or machinery safety. The DCS is not designed to cope with these types of applications and, if a manufacturing process covers multiple disciplines, the DCS will only ever be suitable for part of the system. DCS has, traditionally also been an expensive product to support throughout its life. Annual licensing and support costs can become a significant part of the overall cost of ownership. The majority of DCSs are engineered and supported by the original manufacturer and are not freely available though other channels, leaving the end user reliant on its DCS vendor. Most DCSs had closed and proprietary system architectures. More recently suppliers have adopted more open standards but, in many cases, this approach has limitations which often makes it complicated to integrate with MES and other business systems.

The PLC/SCADA approach

Although PLCs were originally developed for discrete applications, most cover a wide range of applications. The term Programmable Automation Controller (PAC) is now used to describe many products to distinguish them from older systems that were focused on discrete logic. This flexible approach offers multiple programming languages, open communications, and scalability for different applications. There are many systems integrators able to integrate PLC/PAC technology, often with specific industry or application knowledge. This approach is also ideal for OEMs who can select a cost effective product to meet their requirements. Although PLCs and PACs have become more powerful they still have a number of features that are missing when compared to the DCS approach. A typical PLC/SCADA system has at least two databases. The user has to configure the PLC database and then separately configure the database in the SCADA system. At initial engineering stages there may be an option to import the PLC database into the SCADA system but this will require manual modification as changes are made during commissioning and when enhancements are made. If additional software packages are required they are likely to have their own separate databases too, that will need to be configured. Another potential weakness is that not all PLCs have features required for demanding continuous process control applications. In some cases they will lack the ability to modify the system on-line or will not include high availability features like redundancy from I/O modules to supervisory systems. Process optimisation and asset management is another area where traditional PLCs may be lacking compared to a distributed control system.

The best of both worlds

A true ‘Plant-wide Automation’ approach takes the best features from DCS and PLC/SCADA systems and combines them into a single system. It combines the ‘systems approach’ of a DCS and flexibility of a PLC/PAC to provide a solution for multiple applications. This approach has benefits that can improve plant performance and reduce costs. A single architecture can be selected for any application whether it is continuous process control, high-speed OEM equipment or a small batch reactor. It simplifies integration and reduces engineering costs. The resulting system will have a seamless communications architecture allowing access to plant data for process optimisation, asset management and integration with MES. Support costs will also be minimised by reducing training requirements and the cost of holding spares. Rockwell Automation has recognised the benefits of combining the features of Distributed Control Systems and PLC/SCADA solutions into a single Plantwide Automation system with its PlantPAx. As part of the companies Integrated Architecture, it allows a single architecture to be used for a wide range of applications, including process, batch, drives, motion and safety. The importance of being able to address such a wide range of applications is key to a truly plant-wide automation system. Operating any combination of these applications through a purpose-designed single architecture and software environment makes it possible to achieve the benefits of both a DCS and a PLC/SCADA system without many of the traditional downfalls of either. It is this seamless inter-operability that makes plant-wide automation systems so effective. At the core of the PlantPAx is the single database that is used for the Controller, HMI, Historian, Batch Management, Asset Management and Business Intelligence Tool/Reporting Package. Any data created in the system is instantly accessible to all the software packages that need it and a single security model simplifies the management of user’s profiles. The key principles behind this solution can help to drive a lower cost of ownership. Using a single architecture reduces initial engineering and integration costs. The process optimisation and business intelligence tools help to maximise plant efficiency.

Link: http://www.controlengeurope.com/

SCADA Articles

Using Free Tools To Detect Attacks On SCADA Networks
2015-05-09 14:28:25views: 1864

ICS/SCADA experts say open-source network security monitoring software is a simple and cheap way to catch hackers targeting plant operations. Operators at Natanz nuclear facility in Iran might well have caught Stuxnet before it spread and sabotaged operations at the plant if they had been watching the wires for anomalous network traffic, a pair of ICS/SCADA experts say.

Hackers gain full control of critical SCADA systems
2015-05-09 14:04:07views: 1964

Russian researchers have found vulnerabilities in industrial control systems that they say grant full control of systems running energy, chemical and transportation systems. The vulnerabilities were discovered by researchers who over the last year probed popular and high-end ICS and SCADA systems used to control everything from home solar panel installations to critical national infrastructure.

SCADA Attacks Double in 2014
2015-05-06 07:17:15views: 1731

Annual threat report from Dell Security shows not only a significant surge in the number of attacks on retail credit card systems, but industrial SCADA systems as well, which are much more likely to go unreported.
For Dell to report an annual surge in point-of-sale (POS) attacks aimed at payment card infrastructures might not be such a surprise to people who pay any attention to the news.

The Industrial Software Revolution Begins Now
2013-10-16 11:33:59views: 2311

Invensys is kicking off the conference “The Industrial Software Revolution Begins Now” and underscoring the ‘revolution’ concept with the release of its Wonderware InTouch 2014 and Wonderware System Platform 2014 software.

Integrating Video into HMI/SCADA
2012-06-29 10:19:55views: 2594

The useful integration of video with industrial control systems has been a reality for a few years, but a burst of applications and installations is on the horizon. Cheaper bandwidth, wide availability of Internet protocol (IP) cameras, and greater familiarity with industrial Ethernet networks seem to be driving user interest.

AdvancedHMI - a different approach to HMI development
2012-06-14 10:46:48views: 1857

AdvancedHMI base package is a free software used to build HMIs that display information residing in a PLC. You will find it to be one of the fastest platforms to build an HMI with. The software takes advantage of the Visual Basic .NET development environment so effort is focused on the core software and not reinventing a development environment.

Web Services and SCADA
2012-06-12 23:06:33views: 1414

Web services can be another method for connectivity to SCADA and MES systems. They can retrieve tomorrow's weather, the price of stocks or commodities, the time of sunrise and sunset, and a slew of other publicly-available resources.

SCADA virtualisation with WinCC Version 7
2011-12-21 12:01:11views: 1353

As automation solutions become increasingly complex, it follows that the effort required to maintain both hardware and software will also increase. PCs must be provided with suitable specification and operating systems to support the applications.

Cloud-Based SCADA Systems: The Benefits and Risks
2011-12-20 22:57:31views: 970

Cloud computing is a hot topic. As people become increasingly reliant on accessing important information through the Internet, the idea of storing or displaying vital real-time data in the cloud has become more commonplace. With tech giants like Apple, Microsoft, and Google pushing forward the cloud computing concept, it seems to be more than just a passing trend.

An alternative to DCS or PLC/SCADA
2011-10-04 13:46:22views: 923

Traditionally, users have had a choice between a DCS or a PLC/SCADA approach when selecting a control system for use in process control applications. A key benefit of traditional DCSs was that the suppliers took a ‘systems approach’ and it was designed for large scale applications.